What is wrong with using BIPAP specifically? It is similar to CPAP, except can deliver more pressure on inspiration to get past blockages. BIPAP won't force a breath. If you don't breathe, it does nothing. It just marks it as a Central Apnea. That is the way my sleep doctor described it. Now...ASV is totally different, in that it will force you to breathe. ASV shouldnt be used in people with certain heart conditions. You need to have your heart ejection fraction checked, before starting ASV.
But going back to the original post, I had the same onset apneas happen to me a few months ago. My doctors couldn't figure it out. I kept laying down at night, felt jittery/anxious, would fall asleep and immediately wake up, and felt like I wasn't breathing. My BIPAP kept showing CA's occur, which is abnormal for me. I bought a Contec SpO2 monitor to wear overnight, and it showed my oxygen dropping to the low 80's% during each event. I couldn't get any sleep since every time I tried to go to sleep, I'd immediately wake up and felt like I was stopping breathing at night. I'd go a night without sleep. Then the next night was somewhat okay again. But then the cycle kept repeating occassionally. Then a few weeks later, I was hospitalized for DVT/PE blood clots. During in the hospital stay, they put me on a oxygen monitor, and it also showed my levels dropping, whenever I would fall asleep. Yet the doctor didn't seem to care. They just gave me a sleeping pill that night, that really didnt work well.
But now for a few months again, I've been fine. There was only one or two nights where I had this anxious/panic feeling, and tried going to bed and had those same feelings where i was stopping breathing immediately upon falling asleep. VERY WEIRD! My doctor said to either just take melatonin or a half tablet of Klonopin before bed. Which is what I do now, and now I can sleep so far. I hope the issue never comes back. Because I saw many different doctors....neurologists, etc, and they had no answers and blamed it all on anxiety. I just don't see how anxiety could cause Central Apneas and stopping breathing at night though?
I do wish I could get a BIPAP with backup rate though at least, just to have that extra "security" that it would try to make me breathe, whenever i do have Central's. But my sleep doctor keeps saying I don't need it, and that the "backup rate" style machines are old style, and not auto-adjusting. He said if I would have a ton of centrals then I would need ASV.