We use cookies and other tools to enhance your experience on our website and to analyze our web traffic.
For more information about these cookies and the data collected, please refer to our Privacy Policy.

Sierra

Sierra
Joined Jul 2018
Bio

CPAP: AirSense 10 AutoSet

Set to CPAP Fixed Mode

Pressure 11 cm

Ramp: Auto

Ramp Start: 9 cm

EPR: 2, Full Time

Mask: ResMed AirFit P10 Nasal Pillow

Canada

Sierra
Joined Jul 2018
Bio

CPAP: AirSense 10 AutoSet

Set to CPAP Fixed Mode

Pressure 11 cm

Ramp: Auto

Ramp Start: 9 cm

EPR: 2, Full Time

Mask: ResMed AirFit P10 Nasal Pillow

Canada

I had a look at your sleep report. The basic data you covered with a post in your other thread pretty much covers the results. Some comments:

  • you slept about 2.5 hours which is not a lot. Probably on the margin for a valid test.
  • No full apnea events, but quite a few hypopnea and RERA events
  • I found it interesting that they had columns for obstructive hypopnea, and cental hypopnea, but all them were left as unclassified hypopnea. If you were doing another sleep test and trying to decide on a lab, you may want to ask them if they classify the hypopnea events.
  • It appears they are using the Medicare standard for apnea classification which only considers AHI and not RERA events, so you got no diagnosis of apnea.

I am assuming you are located in the US? I found this undated article from what appears to be a US sleep clinic which covers the issue of diagnosis using RDI vs AHI. My short read of it is that Medicare are playing a dirty trick and while they use the term RDI, they exclude RERA events, which makes it essential the same as ADI. And worse still it appears virtually all insurance company follow Medicare rules and ignore RERA. Your insurance company may be different, but it would seem most likely they will not pay for a CPAP unless you meet the AHI criteria. They should pay for a sleep study however.

At What Severity Will Insurance Cover CPAP for Sleep Apnea?

That brings up another question you could ask a prospective sleep clinic you are considering for a study. Do they use Medicare guidelines or American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) guidelines (which include RERA events). If they use AASM that would significantly improve your odds of getting a positive diagnosis and a prescription for a CPAP. You will need a prescription for a new machine even if you pay for it yourself. A used machine may not need a prescription though. Not sure. That article includes a link on where to get a CPAP machine at low cost. One of them is SecondWindCPAP. I believe they are a reputable place to buy from new at a fairly good price, or used. One thing to watch for is that the machine captures detailed data, distinguishes between central and obstructive apnea, and identifies RERA events. The safe bets are the ResMed and Respironics (DreamStation) Auto machines, (ResMed preferred).

I recall I told you before that all your current data suggests you may not benefit from a CPAP. Now that I see the RERA issue more clearly, I have to change my mind. I think it is quite possible that the RERA and hypopnea events may be disturbing you sleep to a significant degree. Just my thoughts, and again I am not a medical professional. Just giving my opinion!

I am not a medical professional, and know little about the issues you have identified, other than the apnea part. Based on your previous thread and reported outcome of a sleep study I recall you had a diagnoses AHI of 4.7 which is just short of the Mild apnea classification based on API. However, I also recall you had some significant RERA events for an overall RDI of 18. In the province in Canada where I am, RDI is used equally with AHI, and you would be classed as having moderate apnea with a RDI of 18. Practice guidelines in this province would then offer a health care covered cost of a CPAP trial. A CPAP trial with an auto machine that records all types of apnea, hypopnea, and RERA would be very informative.

It is possible that the RERA events are a main cause of your sleepiness. They often do not cause the large O2 excursions and are not caught with O2 testing. Good CPAP machines however can detect them. They don't to my knowledge increase pressure based on them though.

The other consideration is that CPAP treatment can create apnea, especially of the central type, and the more pressure you use to treat obstructive apnea the more central apnea may increase. This condition is sometimes called Complex Sleep Apnea. Here is a good article on the subject of Complex Sleep Apnea written by Dr. Robert Thomas, M.D., Associate Professor of Neurology, Harvard Medical School and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center. It can also be found in the Blog section of this site.

When you get your insurance coverage back, I would do another sleep test, and if it confirms an RDI in the 18 range again, then push for a CPAP trial. The machine I would recommend is the ResMed AirSense 10 AutoSet. It will record the data you need to see, and it can be viewed in SleepyHead, so you can come to your own conclusion as well as get one from the Sleep Clinic.

Hope that helps some,

With the Breathewear Halo chin strap I use, I put the P10 mask on first, and then the chin strap second. However, I need the chin strap for two purposes. One is to keep the mask from slipping off, and the other to keep my mouth closed. In your case I can see it may make sense to put the chin strap on first.

On the doctor issue, you need to get someone who has experience with the AirCurve 10 ASV machine. It is a pretty sophisticated and complex machine. Sells for about $5000 on line in Canada. If they were not so expensive I would buy one. I have put that decison off until I am unable to keep AHI under 5 with the standard AutoSet model.

I found a document that you might be interested in. It basically outlines the ResMed view on how to titrate the settings on the various machines, including the ASV model. Here is a link to it:

Sleep Lab Titration Guide

The section that covers your ASV machine starts on page 30. The basic setup for the ASV and ASVAuto modes are given on page 33. Your machine appears to be the basic setup for the ASV mode, but with the EPAP set at 10 cm instead of the recommended starting point of 5 cm. This could be because they tried it in the lab and had to increase EPAP to eliminate obstructive apnea? Or, it could have been just a guess. There is a possibility that it is too high. But that is not certain as your hypopnea has not been eliminated. I do not see any OA events though.

There is another recommended setup for the ASVAuto mode. It is pretty much the same as the ASV except there is a range allowed for the machine to adjust EPAP in, with a recommended setting of 4 cm minimum and 15 max.

So if you can get in to see a doctor that understands the machine, I would ask them if it could be changed to the ASVAuto mode with the recommended default settings. The Auto mode may allow the machine to use less pressure. That in turn would make the mask more comfortable, and hopefully reduce the gas problem too...

Hope that helps some,